By Kelsey Wagner / Editor-in-Chief
Ponca City has never been shy about personality. From our elaborate Italian Revival Marland Mansion to our beautiful priceless art collections at the Ponca City Library, our community has always offered visitors more than a place to pass through. We like to go big, it's sort of our style. So, it's only fitting that our local short-term rentals don't feel like copy-and-paste hotel rooms. They feel like little worlds, all their own.
Around 2018, the first wave of Airbnbs in and around Ponca City began popping up as locals started restoring homes, renovating ranch properties, and reimagining older spaces for guests. I know, because I was one of them. Michael Mattera was the very first person in Ponca City to list rentals on the all-new, peer to peer rental platform Airbnb, and I was the second. When I listed my rental, there were three options. Many of those early listings leaned into a theme on purpose and practicality: small, quaint and cozy. The technology was new and untested, but the platform was quickly gaining steam. Today, if you run a search for Airbnb stays in Ponca City, you will find close to 80 listings, a massive increase over those early years.
And what's changed in those eight years, is the unique theming. Owners have worked hard to bring unique and adventurous decor to their local Airbnbs, in order to make their rentals stand out from the crowd. I thought this was a story worth telling, and I hope you enjoy it! Though we are featuring them in our magazine, these homes are within your grasp through your own quick search on the Airbnb website or mobile app.
Today, these unique, themed rentals help visitors settle in for everything from family get-togethers and sports weekends to hunting trips, lake days, and work travel. Some sit right in town, others are a short drive out. So whether you are looking for a place for your visiting relatives, or you are wanting a staycation right here in our own backyard, these unique rentals are worth showcasing, and are doing their part to bring in visitors and tourists in our lovely little city.
Below are photos and quick descriptions of some of Ponca City's most memorable themed Airbnbs. Find the vibe that fits your trip, and book via the Airbnb or VRBO apps.
Hat Ranch Lodge
This is a spacious and elegant lodge with a western flair. The lodge was completely remodeled in 2018-19. There are 4-5 large bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, 2 living areas, and a newly renovated kitchen and dining area. Two large porches facing east and west allow guests to enjoy the scenic ranch view all day. For those guests that want to experience the country life, but still want all the amenities of town, you'll be happy to know that the Hat Ranch Lodge is less than 10 miles from Ponca City, OK.
Hazel House
Hazel House is a beautiful completely remodeled 1920s home. The owner tried to retain the feel of the 1920's with original doors and lighting. It boasts a beautiful gourmet kitchen, making it perfect for visiting families.
The Fox Den
The Fox Den is a uniquely decorated property, celebrating Ponca City's history and our beloved foxes. This property features original artwork from local artists, as well as books and photos of days gone by. This is a 3 bedroom/1 bath property with a game room or dedicated office space. There is a full kitchen, full size refrigerator, pots/pans, coffee bar, washer and dryer, 2 TVs, and plenty of games and books. It features local art from some of our favorite artists including Chelsea McConnell, Theresa Sacket, and Red Dirt Rosie.
The Gate House
Owner: Lauren Meadors
Built in 1927 by EW Marland as the gatehouse leading up to the Marland Mansion; this property offers a throwback to the oil-boom days of Ponca City. This historic home of the EW Marland Estate boasts 2 king bedrooms, a beautiful library, luxury bathrooms, a designated area to warm food, and a quaint courtyard to relax and enjoy nature.
The Barn House
Located just northeast of Ponca City, this beautifully remodeled 1929 barn offers a unique retreat. With rustic charm and modern comforts, it's perfect for hunters, out-of-town workers, or small groups. Guests enjoy an inviting open-concept space with rustic charm, comfortable sleeping arrangements, and a fully-equipped kitchen. Outside, take in peaceful countryside views and starlit nights. Whether for relaxation or adventure, this extraordinary barn promises an unforgettable stay.
Historic BS Barnes Home
Owner: Larry Buck
Established in 1896, the Historic Barnes House was built by the founder of Ponca City, OK, B.S. Barnes, is nestled in the center of town. With 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, the Historic Barnes House is a great place to stay for your next visit or event, or just a great place to relax.
The Prancing Pony
Welcome to The Prancing Pony, a charming 1948 home blending vintage character with modern comforts. Fully renovated, this cozy retreat features a spacious plush sectional, a comfy king-size bed in the master, a tranquil sunroom, and a private backyard. Enjoy the putting course, dartboard, and warm decor inspired by European Old-World charm. With a washer/dryer and a fully stocked kitchen, it's perfect for long-term stays. Enjoy a cozy and relaxing haven right in the heart of Ponca City.
Lake Road Farm House
Owners: Eric & Erin Liberton, Liberton Investments, LLC
The Lake Road Farmhouse is conveniently located on the east side of Ponca City and is within minutes of everything the community and area lakes and recreation have to offer. Add to that the country and farm feel - it even features farm animals to watch and enjoy too! The nearly 100-year-old property's inside and outside areas will give you a great, quiet place to stay and enjoy while also taking in some relaxation. It's cute, charming, and perfect for a stay in Ponca City!
Hillside Hideaway
Owners: Cody & Amanda Ward
Hillside Hideaway is a cozy cabin retreat located just above the ancient Arkansas River Valley in Ponca City. The property sits on a full 50 acres of heavily wooded land with many mature trees to explore and enjoy. With two large king bedrooms, two small bunk rooms with a full-sized bed, two bathrooms, a cozy office nook, and a playroom full of toys for little ones, it is a great escape for a weekend getaway or family gathering. The property is available for booking on both Airbnb and VRBO.